Sick of mock drafts yet? Well you came to the right place! There’s no mock draft here, at least in any traditional sense. More than likely, you don’t care that much what other NFL teams are doing with their drafts. This blog is called BUCS District after all.
Mock drafts can be fun but prone to tedium by April (ironic considering the more “plugged-in” mock drafters tend to become more accurate the closer the draft is). Consider this the Survivorman, the Mediterranean diet, or Katy Perry’s “Teenage Dream” of mock drafts – emphasis on the essentials to keep you alive for the Bucs 2017 draft outlook. (Was he kidding about Katy Perry? Does it matter?)
All in all, the nineteenth overall pick is not a great spot for value. The Bucs will miss the top talent at position where trading up will still cost a Day 2 pick if not more. Trading down would be ideal but if NFL Twitter is any indication, every team should be trading down this year.
Assuming the Bucs stand at 19, they still have options to add talent to either side of the ball. Bear in mind these rankings do not judge the likelihood of Tampa Bay’s decision but rather Bucs District’s proprietary formula for assessing prospects (i.e. because I said so):
- S Budda Baker, Washington
- RB Dalvin Cook, Florida St.
- RB Leonard Fournette, LSU
- RB Christian McCaffrey, Stanford
- CB Kevin King, Washington
- CB Marlon Humphrey, Alabama
- DE Derek Barnett, Tennessee
- CB Adoree Jackson, USC
- TE David Njoku, Miami
- DT Malik McDowell, Michigan St.
- DE Taco Charlton, Michigan
Bucs District is Bakersville. If Budda Baker were an inch taller and 10 pounds heavier, folks would call him Earl Thomas 2.0. He is the most instinctual defensive back in the draft behind Jamal Adams. With his speed, Baker has the potential to be a NFL single-high safety, a true center-fielder.
The Bucs could do with any of the three running backs. Their ranks here are the result of WordPress making it too onerous to list “2a,” “2b” and “2c.” They each could fit the Bucs in different ways, but they’re each more talented the guys already on the roster.
Kevin King is the kind of cornerback the Bucs need to complement Vernon Hargreaves: tall, rangy and smart. His size and speed could even make him a candidate to switch to free safety, an actual position of need. King also comes from the Washington pedigree of defensive backs that produced Marcus Peters and Desmond Trufant, the NFL’s best corners in 2016.
Barnett is an infuriating prospect. At times he looks like the best pass rusher in the class, practically teleporting around the edge. At others he looks like a Day 2 prospect, slow and ineffective. It’s entirely possible he’s gone by the 19th pick or available afterwards.
Just got around to Adoree Jackson’s film study today, and the appeal is apparent. His blend of ball skills and aggressiveness could make for an exciting NFL defensive back. His size might be less of a concern for a Bucs team that already starts two sub-6′ corners. What should give Jason Licht pause is Jackson’s lapses in discipline and judgment. There were times he appeared out of position defending wide receivers too deep on comebacks and digs.
The belief that the Bucs should draft a tight end in the first round must come from a “best player available” mindset, but selecting David Njoku may take that approach beyond its next logical step. Cam Brate is a great receiving weapon but not much of an inline player. Some might think Njoku would complement that by playing the ever-popular Y-position to Brate’s F tight end. The film simply does not agree. Njoku is not great blocker and appears more enthusiastic when he can do his best Jimmy Graham impression (Quick note: saw Graham in Miami once. His calves are as ridiculous as his hair.)
The day will soon come when ignorant, spoiled Bucs fans will realize how good they had it with Gerald McCoy, which is why the Bucs should start looking at his inevitable replacement if not someone to help extend his career a bit. Malik McDowell is steak tartare compared to Alabama’s Jonathan Allen, but his explosiveness is Michael Bay-like. Opposing offensive linemen often look stunned by the degree of violence McDowell brings. His technique is nonexistent and balance is a question, but he has time to marinate and slow-roast before the Bucs would throw him on the grill.
Taco Charlton is stereotypically raw, that defensive end prospect that appears every year to trick teams into drafting him too high. The Bucs might fall for it, but Jay Hayes has a good track record of molding big, long defensive ends with questionable pass rush technique into productive starters.
So here’s the rub: there’s no one worth trading up for from the 19th pick. Jason Licht would have to surrender entirely too much to reach those too-rich-for-my-blood guys listed in Part 1. This draft is too deep to spend picks to get one guy.
What’s more plausible if not more likely is the Bucs trading down. Adam Schefter already reported that the Bucs are looking to get more picks by trading down, possibly out of the first round. While the offer better be good to surrender that many spots, the draft’s second round is stacked with potential starters.
With that in mind, let’s take a look at the best of the rest from the (unranked) top 100 picks:
- DE Carl Lawson, Auburn
- RB Kareem Hunt, Toledo
- DT Dalvin Tomlinson, Alabama
- RB Samaje Perine, Oklahoma
- S Obi Melifonwu, Connecticut
- TE Jake Butt, Michigan
- TE Evan Ingram, Ole Miss
- DE Tanoh Kpassagnon, Villanova
- RB Alvin Kamara, Tennessee
- RB Marlon Mack, South Florida
- OT Antonio Garcia, Troy
- OT Taylor Moton, Western Michigan
- TE Adam Shaheen, Ashland
- CB Teez Tabor, Florida
- CB Tre’Davious White, LSU
- CB Sidney Jones, Washington
- CB Quincy Wilson, Florida
- DE Tarell Basham, Ohio
- FS Marcus Sanders-Williams, Utah
- SS Jabrill Peppers, Michigan
- WR JuJu Smith-Schuster, USC
- WR Zay Jones, East Carolina
- WR Carlos Henderson, Louisiana Tech
Five running backs!? It’s almost as though the Bucs don’t need to draft a running back in the first round. My favorite for the Bucs is Kareem Hunt, a compact runner with impeccable balance and vision. He’s a tackle-breaking machine and could be had for the low low price of a third round pick.
This draft is certainly not lacking for tight end depth. The key for the Bucs is fit. They need a do-it-all, inline tight end to complement Cam Brate. Evan Ingram is a glorified slot receiver who is wasted as a blocker. Jake Butt is the smart Day 2 pick, but don’t sleep on D-II powerhouse Adam Shaheen. He’s big, athletic and blocks like an OT. His underdeveloped skill set makes him a third round prospect at best, but nonetheless deserving of consideration.
Don’t count out offensive linemen entirely. Troy OT Antonio Garcia is raw but packed with potential. He has nimble feet and a mean streak befitting the right tackle spot once the Bucs move on from Demar Dotson.
Typically the defensive tackle prospects thin out after the first round, and this year is no different. Tomlinson is probably the best of the remaining bunch but he’s a poor fit with the Bucs as a 2-gap space eater. Don’t expect the Bucs to waste a pick on the interior defensive line after the first round.
The Bucs might want to go back to Florida for their cornerback needs. Tabor and Wilson aren’t the fastest or most disciplined backs, but they’re both physical and aggressive, key Mike Smith defense traits.
The second round is primed for a Bucs’ defensive end pick. Carl Lawson is a first round talent getting no respect from mock draft circles. He would give the Bucs even more speed off the edge. Call me a fan of smaller school prospects, but I like Kpassagnon and Basham. Kpassagnon is exactly the kind of end Mike Smith and Jay Hayes seem to prefer. Basham needs seasoning but his explosiveness and agility are more than a little intriguing.
With our key prospects identified, we can start examining scenarios. If the Bucs stay at 19, odds are good they take one of the top remaining running backs. Which one I can’t say for certain but if Cook is available I’d say he’s the favorite.
Scenario 1: Bucs Stay at 19
- Round 1: RB Dalvin Cook
- Round 2: TE Jake Butt
- Round 3: DE Tanoh Kpassagnon
In the second scenario, the Bucs take advantage of this year’s bountiful defensive offerings and somehow land DE Derek Barnett. That’s rounded out by the powerful Marlon Mack and some secondary help in Teez Tabor.
- Round 1: DE Derek Barnett
- Round 2: RB Marlon Mack
- Round 3: CB Teez Tabor
In the increasingly likely trade down scenarios, the Bucs pick up another more top 100 pick. Schefter’s tweet about trading out of the first round is a strong indication the Bucs are talking to the Browns, who own two second round picks. In that situation:
- Round 2: DE Carl Lawson
- Round 2: S Obi Melifonwu
- Round 2: WR JuJu Smith-Schuster
- Round 3: RB Kareem Hunt
Quite a haul. The Bucs address four different positions with players who can provide immediate impacts. This is definitely the volume haul, if not the most ideal. Melifonwu best fits as a box safety, of which the Bucs already have two. They do get a steal in Kareem Hunt though.
In scenario four, the Bucs get an additional 3rd round pick from a 2016 playoff team, possibly the Cowboys or the Texans in their hunt for a quarterback.
- Round 1: S Budda Baker
- Round 2: DE Tarell Basham
- Round 3: RB Kareem Hunt
- Round 3: WR Carlos Henderson
The pattern should be apparent by now that the trade down scenarios give the Bucs maximum flexibility and range to address their roster. All four guys play with a good bit of fire and tenacity. This is my ideal 2017 draft for the Buccaneers.